Councilwoman in Hot Water: Alleged Forgery in Ballot Petition Scandal

Person examining documents with a magnifying glass.

The scandal involving Saginaw City Councilwoman Monique Lamar-Silvia circles around alleged forged ballot petition signatures, potentially entangling her in legal strings.

At a Glance

  • Monique Lamar-Silvia faces allegations of forging signatures on ballot petitions.
  • Surveillance video captured at Saginaw City Hall reportedly shows the forgery occurring.
  • Eric Eggleston, the candidate in question, fell short on necessary signatures.
  • The Secretary of State’s office has launched an investigation into the potential legal violation.

Investigation Unfolds

Monique Lamar-Silvia stands accused of falsifying signatures on nominating petitions for Eric Eggleston, a Saginaw City Council candidate. Surveillance footage from Saginaw City Hall purports to show the councilwoman engaged in this activity before the submission deadline. The video, obtained via the Freedom of Information Act, became a cornerstone in the probe conducted by Michigan election regulators. Eggleston missed the nomination due to insufficient valid signatures.

The allegations against Lamar-Silvia have drawn increased scrutiny from state election officials. The Saginaw City Clerk, Kristine Bolzman, flagged three suspicious signatures as possibly being fraudulent, pushing the Secretary of State’s office to intervene. Despite the lack of sufficient endorsements, Lamar-Silvia continues her re-election campaign. She’s yet to address the allegations publicly, leaving her political future shrouded in uncertainty.

Eggleston’s Shortfall

Eric Eggleston, founder of a local youth organization, discovered he needed six additional signatures to meet the candidate requirements for the Saginaw City Council. He and Lamar-Silvia were seen pursuing late endorsements outside City Hall. Despite efforts and one confirmed signature from another candidate, Carly Hammond, Eggleston did not qualify for a spot on the ballot. Nonetheless, he remains supportive of Lamar-Silvia, even as his council pursuit falters.

Previously a council member since 2021, Lamar-Silvia now faces possible felony charges stemming from the accusation of fraudulent signature work. The investigation’s outcome might affect her chances in the approaching election period. As absentee voting kicks in, Lamar-Silvia’s standing on the ballot underscores her unresolved electoral challenges—both legally and publically.

Electoral Implications

Monique Lamar-Silvia’s re-election campaign is overshadowed by allegations of electoral fraud. The Secretary of State’s formal inquiry could eventually lead to a felony conviction if fraudulent activity is proven. Her involvement in an alleged scheme to help a fellow council hopeful might have significant legal and political repercussions. For an elected representative, adherence to electoral integrity is non-negotiable, ensuring democratic processes remain unsullied.

Following these developments, Saginaw voters must evaluate the unfolding situation critically. As new information surfaces, the community will determine how these revelations impact their trust in local governance. Amidst these challenges, Michigan’s broader effort to tighten election integrity grows ever-relevant in ensuring fair elections for its constituents.

Sources:

  1. Video captures Saginaw councilwoman allegedly falsifying names on ballot petitions
  2. Watch video of Saginaw councilwoman allegedly falsifying names on ballot petition forms
  3. Saginaw council member under investigation for allegedly falsifying petition signatures